Immigrant Rights are Human Rights/No Human Being Is Illegal

Here’s one I wrote a while back that I think is particularly timely now. When we forget history, we risk becoming its victims.

A few years ago, a former Mayor of Portland, Oregon asked me the question, “why are immigrant rights human rights?” I responded with a clumsy jumble of words having something to do with the United Nations and about ten other things adding up to a total of about 11 too many ideas all poorly articulated.

5 minutes after leaving his office the answer I wish I’d given came to me. I ran it over in my head all the way home. It went something like this:

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights was written in 1948, three years after the end of World War II. The Nazi atrocities committed during that war inspired the United Nations to convene The Commission on Human Rights to draft the Declaration as a foundation upon which the Commission would create covenants and conventions that aspired to ensure that atrocities like those committed in Nazi Germany could never be repeated.

Approximately 6 million Jews were killed by Nazis. In addition, between 250 thousand and 1.5 million Romani, 25,000 LGBT people, 2-3 million Russian prisoners of war, and as many as 2 million ethnic Slavs were also killed.

In the face of such horrors, it was deemed necessary to acknowledge the right of people to move freely, including the right to cross national borders and seek asylum from persecution and oppression.

That’s why immigration is a human right.

These rights are described in Articles 13 and 14. They read,

Article 13.

  • (1) Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each state.
  • (2) Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country.

Article 14.

  • (1) Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution.

Today, in order to live by the spirit of Universal Declaration of Human Rights, if not the original wording of its writers, we have to address the many forces beyond war and political persecution that drive migration.

For example, consider Mexico. Unfair U.S. trade policies such as the North American Free Trade Agreement have devastated the Mexican economy. It is the most powerful force driving Mexicans to immigrate to the U.S. without documents. These people over whose heads we are fighting about “illegal” immigration are economic refugees.

And they are only among the latest wave.

For decades, U.S. agribusiness has laid claim to rich agricultural lands in the global south. Once there they turn farmers into farm workers and inwardly directed economies where people grow crops and make things they their own consumption into outwardly directed economies based on growing single crops such as pineapples, or sugar for export. The people of these communities become dependent on the wages they receive from multinational corporations and these corporations’ local contractors. Over generations, they may even lose the knowledge necessary to return to what they once were.

Regardless, when more profitable labor markets open elsewhere, companies leave and communities are devastated. People are impoverished and then driven out, forced to follow the money. But though capital is free to cross borders, people are not. By building fences legally or literally, we are banishing them to a kind of poverty most of us in the U.S. could not begin to imagine.

And agribusiness is only one type of enterprise that is robbing people around the world of sovereignty and self-determination.

Our understanding of human rights must adapt to a changing world. As long as capital can move freely, making people dependent on foreign incomes, people should be able to follow the profits they helped to produce, even if it means crossing our national borders.

5 Responses to Immigrant Rights are Human Rights/No Human Being Is Illegal

Before posting a comment, please read our comment guidelines.

  1. Susie February 28, 2013 at 3:09 pm #

    Dear Scot,
    This was extremely educational and quite moving. I asked my husband (43) our Son (17) and our Daughter (14) if anyone coups tell me what The Universal Declaration of Human Rights was and our Son Forrest was the only one who had, and not because he leaned it in school, because he reads everything he can get his hands on. I am not shocked, but saddened that our children where never taught this in school, thank you for this valuable lesson.

    • Scot Nakagawa
      Scot Nakagawa February 28, 2013 at 4:32 pm #

      Love this comment. Thank you

    • Scot Nakagawa
      Scot Nakagawa March 19, 2013 at 3:51 pm #

      Thanks, Susie! I hope it was helpful and if you want recommendations of reading material, I’m happy to send them your way!

  2. Damien Haynes March 24, 2013 at 4:08 pm #

    This is information that should be distributed to all masses and not withheld. NAFTA has had it’s effect on the countries that are producing crops and has left nothing for the natives of those countries to show for it other then an impoverished nation. It is no wonder why those people seek refuge and financial upward mobility in well developed nations.

    • Scot Nakagawa
      Scot Nakagawa March 24, 2013 at 4:38 pm #

      Thanks, Damien! Feel free to spread it around!

Before posting a comment, please read our comment guidelines.