President Obama – Not Ahead of the Curve

Today President Obama acted by directive to provide a 2 year “deferred action” on deportation of undocumented immigrants who were brought to the U.S. as children. I’m overjoyed at the change. But am I grateful? Nope. I say it’s about time and, BTW, not enough.

No doubt the directive was prompted by the fact that the Republicans were about to announce a proposal via Marco Rubio meant to build support for the Republican Party among Latino voters.

I know that the Rubio proposal was just a political maneuver with no teeth. I’m not lauding Republicans. But never doubt that they, not human rights advocates, drove this decision. This had to do with the Obama team winning the Latino vote in the upcoming election by outflanking the other side. We deny this at the expense of our ability to get ahead of our national leaders; to get behind the wheel of our policy agenda and not just consign ourselves to the role of political backseat drivers.

The directive was the issue driving discussion on the Dylan Ratigan show today. In the discussion on air, liberal pundit Krystal Ball touted the President’s “courage” on social issues, citing his recent statement of support of same-sex marriage as “ahead of the curve.”

I was frustrated with the too little and, for many, too late directive, but I’ll admit that Ball’s statement was what got me writing. Ahead of the curve on same sex marriage? Courage in regard to immigrant rights? I call b.s.

I mean, if the order today and Obama’s statement in support of same sex marriage are ahead of the curve, we need a new curve.

On the issue of marriage, is the President ahead of the curve by evolving to support in an election year when young voters, overwhelmingly in support of same sex marriage, will be a factor at the polls? Only if that curve is drawn by pollsters, and not by the moral imperative at stake in this issue.

And concerning the deferred action on deportation? I won’t call it courage to finally provide temporary relief for a problem requiring a permanent solution, and years ago.

According to the ACLU:

In 2010…363,000 immigrants [were held] in detention in over 250 facilities… Among those locked up for months or years are survivors of torture, asylum seekers, victims of trafficking, families with small children, the elderly, individuals with serious medical and mental health conditions, and lawful permanent residents…who are facing deportation because of old or minor crimes.

In the immigration system, 84% of detainees have no lawyer. They are denied bond and can be held indefinitely. Many are detained for years without ever going to court to determine whether their detention was legal to begin with.

And those with past convictions are not the whole story. In fact, they are a red herring of sorts, distracting us from the fact that nearly half of those deported in 2011 had no past criminal conviction. Their only “crime” was crossing the border without papers. And once arrested, their human rights were not a consideration. Apparently in the U.S., the self described human rights champion, the only people counted as “human” and therefore eligible for rights consideration are citizens.

Krystal Ball should be ashamed of herself, calling out POTUS for being “ahead of the curve.”

How many same sex couples have been dissolved by death, with the survivor being excluded from the last moments of life of their loved one? How many have been excluded from wills? How long have same sex couples had to tolerate being treated as second class citizens, their basic humanity debated, while POTUS evolved?

And how many immigrant families have been torn apart, parents separated from children, husbands from wives, while we’ve waited for this temporary reprieve?

Why do we allow this kind of horse trading on matters of basic human dignity and human rights? And when those with the power to do something act, why does the “curve” get set at the point where they decide to act, and not along the lines of the lives of those for whom these decisions have life changing consequences?

It’s time for us to move the baseline on courage in America. If we don’t, I’m afraid of where following that curve will lead us.

, , , , , , , , ,

6 Responses to President Obama – Not Ahead of the Curve

Before posting a comment, please read our comment guidelines.

  1. Patty June 15, 2012 at 11:21 pm #

    true. preach.

  2. Lillian June 16, 2012 at 2:52 am #

    Indeed! There are acts of courage and there are acts of political expediency… we need bold acts of courage because it’s the right thing to do–election year or not.

  3. anon June 16, 2012 at 8:36 am #

    hi. i was wondering if you had sources for some of the statistics you cited. NOT AT ALL b/c I doubt your post or your blog but because it would just be personally helpful for me in backing these things up. I’ve definitely read/know of similar things and similar numbers. Unfortunately I live in a social sphere where these statements can’t be made and taken as an obvious form of the fucked up U.S. politic without (the always problematic) reliance on “evidence”…

    • Scot Nakagawa
      Race Files June 16, 2012 at 11:52 am #

      If you mean on the immigrant detention issue, the aclu has a lot of information on their site. I linked to them in the article. That link will take you directly to their website where they have a lot of resourced. Another good source of information is the National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights. Good luck!

  4. Julie F June 16, 2012 at 2:16 pm #

    Good post. The arc of justice bends oh-so-slowly. Thanks for trying to speed it up.

    • Scot Nakagawa
      Race Files June 16, 2012 at 2:31 pm #

      If we all grab hold of it together and start pulling, maybe we’ll get there.

Leave a Reply

Before posting a comment, please read our comment guidelines.